Author – Shikha Shah
In 2012, I had to undergo induction training at my first job as a young social development professional. As part of it, I stayed in a house of a marginal farmer in a remote village of Mandla district, Madhya Pradesh called Banjara Tola. I still remember walking alone to a barren field every morning, around 500 meters away from the mud house I had stayed in. Carrying a bottle of water and soap in hand, I had to cross patches of corn fields and a small stony stream to answer nature’s call.
Finishing the task, I washed my hands in the same stream from which many times water was fetched for washing, cooking and drinking. It was the most self-conscious and uncomfortable part of my life till now.
The problem – Poor Sanitation
There cannot be a better way to understand sanitation issues like open defecation and personal hygiene than by personally experiencing it. In Banjara Tola, I discovered that hundreds of Indian villages lacked toilets due to many physical and financial constraints apart from people’s cultural choices. With low water table and no perennial streams, many villages could not construct flush toilets. Marginality had further pushed them to use even the money under government sanitation schemes for other immediate needs like food, health and agriculture.
Poor sanitation has only degraded our environment and affected human health regardless of losing billions of dollars every year in search of solution. It has disgraced our nation and affected tourism too. Inefficient in making stakeholders realize the importance of household sanitation, recent developments has adopted a demand-driven, community-led, public-private partnership-based decentralized approach for better implementation of national policies and schemes.
The solution – EcoSan Toilets
Role of the private sector, NGOs, Community organizations, civil society and international agencies is crucial in creating some successful sanitation/toilet models, which can be replicated on a large scale and included in new policies and laws. Among these models, the Ecological Sanitation (EcoSan) toilet model has emerged as a sustainable concept to troubleshoot sanitation problem in rural India.
The Indian subcontinent has a diverse topography and uneven distribution of water resources, which requires a water-efficient toilet model to ensure mass implementation. EcoSan has come up with toilet designs without a flush consuming less water with uncompromised hygiene. The basic concept of EcoSan’s dry composting toilet is to manage human excreta and urine separately by decomposing them into useful organic resources, which can be handled safely and used in agriculture without harming our environment.
EcoSan toilets consist of two pits (one for use and one for composting) and separate outlets for urine and anal wash water diversion. Usually, these pits are designed to suffice for a five-member family for 5-6 months, after which the second pit is used and excreta in the first pit is left to decompose. After every toilet use, a handful of ash has to be thrown over excreta to create optimum conditions for waste decomposition by microorganisms into nutrient rich fertilizer (rich in potash and nitrogen). Urine and waste water (rich in ammonia) collected in a separate chamber can be used for vegetable and flower beds.
Variations in the design of EcoSan toilets using appropriate technology to suit local area requirements have been done. Some examples of thriving models of these dry composting toilets can be seen in Gujarat, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, Orissa, Bihar and Ladakh. Voluntary organizations such as Myrada, Eco Solutions, UNICEF, WaterAction, Wherever The Need, etc. have designed toilets that are running efficiently in urban, semi-urban, rural and coastal areas.
These pictures show the construction of EcoSan toilets in a village in Andhra Pradesh
Bio-toilet is another emerging technology using variety of bacteria strains to convert human waste into non-toxic, non-contaminating water that can be safely disposed in water bodies or can be used for irrigation. It is being used in Gulbarga, Karnataka.
A self flushing e-toilet (using concept of pay & use toilet scheme) are toilets that are designed in such a way that it flushes itself on entry and exit with a drop of coin. They are prevalent in Delhi, Kerala and Mumbai for footpath and slum dwellers.
Cool innovation, this can reduce the disease caused due to the poor sanitation in rural areas. Thanks for bringing this up to us.
Are this toilets available in all the states? Is government helping the poor to get this one build?
@sulekha Hi..No these toilets are not available in all the states right now. Indian states with EcoSan toilet models are mentioned in above article. For more information you can check this link
And yes government is funding for these toilets in some states.
I need these kind of toilets can you provide me details of manufacture
Hi Shikha, EcoSan artcle makes for a nice reading. However, I want to know which are the organizations promoting this concept? What is the cost involved? Do the community involvement taken into considearion in cash or in kind? Has there been any collaboration with local panchayats to spread this initiative at a larger scale?
some of the organizations promoting and facilitating this concept are mentioned in the last section or article. About the government funding and cost details..i will detail you soon.
There is this UK based organization called ‘wherever the need’ who are piloting eco san toilets in India, mostly in Tamil Nadu for now. they have a model which can cater around 350 women and children costing around Rs 350000 or Rs 1000 per person.
Myrada is also promoting ecosan toilets partnering with many national and international organizations mostly in Karnataka. they have a unit for one family costing around Rs 13000 -15000. In many villages partnering with panchayats has reduced the cost in form of labor and material contribution.
Some state governments has included Ecological Sanitation as main agenda in their health schemes too.
 Can we replace toilet construction by material like fiber glass, ABS etc to extent possible instead of concrete?. This will bring in precast concept, just do assembly at site. This is also bring in minimum works at site.What is cost of each toiler ? who make them?
Ofcourse you put fiber glass, ABS etc. provided they can tolerate rural environmental conditions and can be repaired by villagers when required. Concrete is something people are used to, so they can maintain it at their level in times of need.
Cost of toilets vary according to size and model. You can read my previous comment to check prices by some of the Indian organizations. Also, check the links in reference section for more info.
I am helping a school to build toile for girls.
we have collected some 2 lacs but are short of by just 3 lacs total budget is 5 lacs. They have old design as usual prevailing in India. Can we build these toilets in schools? Will it be cost effective?
Hi Rajkumar, visit the link above. It gives very good cost estimates of toilets that can be build in rural areas. Now about your design, the cost depends on how many units of toilets (depending on number of girls in school) you are planning to build. You should contact one the above mentioned organizations may be, they will give to a very clear idea of things.
Excellent read Shikha. Can you tell me which one of the two eco-friendly technologies from Ecosan and Bio toilets is cost effective and more feasible to manage at HH level? Any organization supplying these on commercial terms in bulk?
Excellent info. Shikha. Can you let me know which of the two mentioned Toilet tech. from Bio and Ecosan is cost effective at HH level and if there is any commercial outfit supplying these?
[…] survey took into account the components of ‘Swachh Bharat Mission’ such as construction of toilets, solid waste management and independent observation for its […]
[…] with bio-toilets, which were developed by Indian Railways in collaboration with DRDO. These bio-toilets contain tanks below them, which collect human waste and are decomposed by consortium bacteria. Only […]
I would like to have these Toilets in our Project in Bhubaneswar,Jodhpur and Delhi, kindly share contact nos who can help me out to have these toilets in above Cities.
we are planing such a toilet here in India-Andrah Pradesh. Do you know any manufacturers here, where we can buy such a squatting pan?
Thanks a lot.
Hi Shikha ji I am working with Sbm we want to made bio toilet in hilly area and rock area kindly send details with drawing so we can make
Thank you very much for your interest in building toilets in rural areas. please mail us at info @ecoideaz.com so that we can get Shikhaji to reply
I would like to ask that, how can we connect people to nature? Is this one of the method?
Who are the designers involved in these ?